What Firmness Level Do Most People Prefer?

Understanding Mattress Firmness Levels

Mattress firmness is rated on a scale from 1 to 10:

· 1–2: Extremely soft

· 3–4: Plush

· 5–6: Medium

· 7–8: Firm

· 9–10: Extra-firm

This scale is subjective, but manufacturers use it to help consumers compare products. Your weight, sleep style, and mattress materials all affect how a bed feels.

Why Firmness Matters

The right firmness level ensures:

· Spinal alignment

· Pressure relief

· Even weight distribution

· Comfort throughout the night

Choosing the wrong firmness can lead to aches, tossing, and poor sleep quality.

Survey Results: What People Actually Prefer

A national sleep survey of over 1,500 participants found the following preferences:

· 58% preferred medium-firm (5–6 rating)

· 23% preferred firm (7–8 rating)

· 15% preferred plush (3–4 rating)

· 4% preferred ultra-soft or extra-firm extremes

Most users cited balance as the reason behind choosing medium-firm it provides comfort and support for multiple sleep positions.

Firmness by Sleep Position

1. Side Sleepers:

· Best with plush to medium

· Need pressure relief at shoulders and hips

2. Back Sleepers:

· Medium to firm

· Require spinal support and lower back stability

3. Stomach Sleepers:

· Firm to extra-firm

· Prevents hips from sinking and misaligning spine

Firmness by Body Weight

Body Weight	Ideal Firmness	Why?
Under 130 lbs	Plush–Medium	Less weight = less sinkage
130–230 lbs	Medium–Firm	Balanced support & cushion
230+ lbs	Firm–Extra-Firm	Prevents sagging, supports heavier frame

Visual Graph: Most Preferred Firmness Level

Comparison Table: Firmness Types

Firmness Level	Best For	Pros	Cons
Plush	Side sleepers, lightweight	Excellent pressure relief	May lack support
Medium	Combo sleepers, couples	Balanced feel	Might not be ideal for specific needs
Firm	Back/stomach sleepers, heavy	Good alignment	Less contour and softness

Top Mattress Picks by Firmness Level

1. Plush: Eclipse Cares Collection Joyfulness Hybrid 11" Plush Mattress

Overview:
This plush hybrid mattress blends traditional pocketed coil support with plush foam comfort layers, offering an inviting feel perfect for side sleepers and lightweight individuals. The quilted cover and breathable design provide a cool, cozy sleep environment while still maintaining responsive support from the coil system.

Key Features:

· 11” Profile: Balanced height that fits most standard bed frames.

· Individually Wrapped Coils: Enhance motion isolation and adapt to body contours.

· Plush Foam Layers: Designed to cushion pressure points.

· Breathable Cover: Helps regulate temperature throughout the night.

· CertiPUR-US Certified Foams: Ensures safe and durable materials.

Pros	Cons
Excellent pressure relief for side sleepers	May lack lumbar support for heavier sleepers
Plush, contouring surface	Too soft for stomach or back sleepers
Good airflow due to hybrid build	May develop body impressions over time
Low motion transfer for partner comfort	Less bounce than traditional innersprings

Check Price

2. Medium: Premium Comfort Prelude Medium Mattress by Scandinavian

Overview:
The Prelude Medium mattress is a well-rounded option for combination sleepers or couples with mixed preferences. Crafted with layers of high-density support foam and responsive comfort foam, it promotes spinal alignment without being too soft or too firm. Scandinavian design influences both the performance and minimalist aesthetic.

Key Features:

· Balanced Medium Feel: Great for all sleep positions.

· Multi-Layer Foam Core: Provides a combination of pressure relief and support.

· Reinforced Edges: Better edge support and usable sleep surface.

· Soft-Touch Cover: Hypoallergenic and breathable.

· Motion-Reducing Technology: Ideal for sharing with a partner.

Pros	Cons
Versatile firmness for most sleepers	May be too generic for sleepers with very specific needs
Balanced contour and bounce	Not ideal for those needing extra lumbar support
Modern Scandinavian build quality	Limited height may not suit taller bed frames
Great motion isolation	Lacks the deep contouring of memory foam

Check Price

3. Firm: Diamond DreamStage Collection 2.0 Grace Firm Gel Swirl Memory Foam 12" Mattress

Overview:
This firm mattress is ideal for back and stomach sleepers seeking strong support with a touch of pressure reliefz. Featuring advanced gel swirl memory foam, the Grace Firm provides a cool sleeping experience while reducing pressure points without losing firmness. It supports heavier body types well and resists sagging over time.

Key Features:

· Gel Swirl Memory Foam: Regulates temperature and reduces pressure buildup.

· High-Density Base Foam: Delivers firm, stable support.

· 12” Profile: Offers a luxury feel and added durability.

· CertiPUR-US Certified: Free from harmful chemicals and emissions.

· Quilted Top Layer: Adds a hint of initial softness before firm support kicks in.

Pros	Cons
Ideal for stomach and back sleepers	May feel too firm for side sleepers
Great spinal alignment and posture support	Not suitable for those who prefer a plush feel
Cool-sleeping memory foam	Firmer sleep surface may take adjustment
Long-lasting durability	Minimal body contouring

Check Price

Conclusion

Firmness is subjective but survey data helps clarify common preferences. The majority of sleepers lean toward medium-firm because it accommodates most positions and body types. However, the best mattress for you depends on personal comfort, support needs, and health considerations.

Visit your local showroom, try out various firmness levels, and remember: comfort is king. What feels right for you is the best choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What firmness level is best for back pain?
Medium-firm mattresses are often recommended by chiropractors for spinal alignment and support.

2. Is firm better than plush?
Not necessarily firm is better for support, plush is better for pressure relief. It depends on your sleep style.

3. Are medium mattresses good for couples?
Yes, medium mattresses balance softness and support, making them great for couples with different preferences.

4. How do I know if my mattress is too firm?
If you wake up with shoulder or hip pain or feel pressure points, it may be too firm.

5. Can a mattress be too soft?
Yes, a too-soft mattress can lead to poor spinal alignment and back pain.

6. Should heavy people choose firm mattresses?
Yes, heavier individuals benefit from firmer mattresses  that prevent sinking and provide durable support.

7. Do memory foam mattresses feel softer?
Yes, memory foam conforms closely to your body and typically feels softer than innerspring or latex.

8. How long does it take to adjust to a new mattress?
Most people need 2–4 weeks to adjust to a new mattress.

9. Does mattress firmness change over time?
Yes, all mattresses soften slightly over time with use.

10. Can I make my mattress softer or firmer?
Yes, use a mattress topper to adjust firmness without replacing the whole bed.