How to Choose the Best Bed Sheets: Thread Count, Fabric & Fit Explained
Our recommendations are based on hands-on testing in 5 LA showrooms and feedback from 3,300+ verified customers.

01How to Choose the Best Bed Sheets
The right sheets make a real difference in how well you sleep. The wrong ones can leave you too hot, too scratchy, or constantly tucking corners back under the mattress at 2 a.m.
Here's what actually matters — and what you can ignore.
03Thread Count: What It Really Means
Thread count measures how many threads are woven into one square inch of fabric — horizontally and vertically combined. It's widely marketed as the main indicator of quality, but it's not the whole story.
The useful range is 200–400. Below 200, sheets often feel rough. Above 400, manufacturers sometimes inflate numbers by counting twisted or multi-ply threads as multiple individual threads — which doesn't improve feel or durability.
A 300 thread count sheet made from long-staple Egyptian cotton will feel significantly better than a 600 thread count sheet made from short-fiber cotton or a cotton-polyester blend.
Bottom line: Thread count matters, but fabric quality matters more.
04Fabric Types: What to Know Before You Buy
Long-Staple Cotton (Egyptian, Pima, Supima)
The best all-around cotton. Long fibers produce a smoother, more durable weave that resists pilling. Egyptian-long staple, Pima, and Supima are the labels to look for. These cost more, but they last longer and feel better over time.
Percale
A crisp, flat weave — cooler to the touch than sateen and very durable. Usually cotton or a cotton blend. A great choice if you sleep warm or just prefer that clean, hotel-linen feel. Gets softer with every wash.
Sateen
A silky, slightly lustrous finish. Sateen feels warmer and softer out of the package than percale, but it's more delicate and can snag or pill over time. If you go sateen, stick with 300–600 thread count from a quality brand.
Flannel
Made from brushed cotton (or sometimes a blend), flannel is warm, soft, and cozy. Ideal for cold months. Not what you want in a warm climate or during summer — heat retention is high.
Cotton-Polyester Blend
Budget-friendly and wrinkle-resistant. Polyester adds durability, but the blend doesn't breathe as well as 100% cotton. If you're a hot sleeper, this is probably not your best option. Good for a guest room or if easy care is the priority.
Jersey
Think T-shirt material. Soft, stretchy, and casual. Breathes reasonably well in natural fiber versions. Less structured than percale — suits people who prioritize softness over that crisp feel.
Muslin
The most affordable option. Thread counts around 130. Rough and basic — functional but not comfortable for most sleepers. Generally not worth it unless budget is the only factor.
Organic Cotton and Bamboo
Grown without pesticides, organic cotton is worth considering if you have allergies or skin sensitivities. Bamboo-derived fabrics are naturally moisture-wicking and temperature-regulating, though quality varies widely by manufacturer.
05Chemical Finishes: What You're Not Told
Most commercially produced sheets are treated with chemical finishes to resist wrinkles, prevent shrinking, and hold shape. Common agents include formaldehyde-based resins and silicone treatments.
This is why brand-new sheets sometimes feel stiff or smell slightly chemical. Washing them two or three times before first use helps significantly.
If you have allergies or chemical sensitivities, look for "pure finish" or "chemical-free" labeling, or opt for certified organic sheets (look for OEKO-TEX or GOTS certification).
Jacquard sheets are woven with patterns built into the fabric itself rather than printed on — no extra chemical dye process, and a more luxurious look. These sit at the high end of the price range.
06Getting the Right Fit: Pocket Depth
Sheet sizing is standardized (twin, full, queen, king, California king), but fit varies because mattress thickness has increased significantly over the past decade. Pillow-tops, euro-tops, and thick comfort layers mean many mattresses are now 14–18 inches tall or more.
If your sheets keep popping off at night, pocket depth is almost always the culprit.
| Mattress Height | Pocket Depth to Look For |
|---|---|
| Up to 12 inches | Standard (10–12 inches) |
| 13–17 inches | Deep pocket (15–17 inches) |
| 18–25 inches | Extra deep pocket (20–25 inches) |
Rule of thumb: Add 2 inches to your mattress height when selecting pocket depth. A little extra is better than sheets that don't reach. Sheet clips (also called sheet straps) can also help secure looser-fitting sheets.
If pocket depth isn't listed on the packaging, "standard" usually means 12 inches or less. If your mattress is taller, contact the manufacturer or look for brands that list exact pocket depth.
07Sheet Fabric Comparison at a Glance
| Fabric | Feel | Breathability | Durability | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long-staple cotton | Smooth, soft | Excellent | High | Most sleepers |
| Percale | Crisp, cool | Excellent | High | Hot sleepers |
| Sateen | Silky, warm | Moderate | Moderate | Cold sleepers |
| Flannel | Fuzzy, warm | Low | Moderate | Winter / cold climates |
| Cotton-poly blend | Smooth, firm | Moderate | High | Budget / easy care |
| Jersey | Stretchy, soft | Good | Moderate | Casual sleepers |
| Organic cotton | Varies | Excellent | High | Allergy-sensitive sleepers |
| Bamboo-derived | Silky, smooth | Excellent | Moderate | Hot sleepers, sensitive skin |
08Quick Buying Checklist
- Measure your mattress height before shopping
- Choose pocket depth with 2 inches of clearance
- Pick fabric based on sleep temperature, not just price
- Look for thread count between 200–400
- Prioritize fiber quality over thread count number
- Wash new sheets 2–3 times before first use
- Check for OEKO-TEX or GOTS certification if you want chemical-free
09Frequently Asked Questions
Is a higher thread count always better?
No. Thread count is one factor among several. A 400 thread count sheet made from short-staple cotton can feel worse than a 200 thread count sheet made from Pima or Egyptian long-staple cotton. Focus on fiber quality first, thread count second.
What's the best sheet material for hot sleepers?
Percale cotton or bamboo-derived fabric. Both breathe well and wick moisture efficiently. Avoid sateen and flannel if you tend to sleep warm.
Why do my fitted sheets keep coming off?
Almost always a pocket depth issue. Measure your mattress height and choose sheets with at least 2 inches more pocket depth than your mattress is tall.
Should I wash new sheets before using them?
Yes. New sheets often contain chemical finishes applied during manufacturing. Washing 2–3 times removes residue and softens the fabric.
What does "pure finish" mean on sheet packaging?
It means the sheets were not treated with the standard chemical finishing agents. A good option if you have skin sensitivities or chemical allergies.
Are Egyptian cotton sheets worth the price?
Genuine Egyptian long-staple cotton is among the best available — softer, more durable, and better-feeling than standard cotton. The caveat: the label "Egyptian cotton" is often misused. Look for GIZA certification or buy from reputable brands.
10Need Help Choosing the Right Sleep Setup?
Great sheets pair best with the right mattress underneath them. If your mattress is older than 7–8 years or you're waking up stiff and unrested, the sheets won't fix the underlying problem.
Visit any of our 5 LA Mattress Store showrooms to try different comfort levels in person — or browse our full mattress collection online. Our sleep experts can help match you with the right combination of mattress, support, and bedding for how you actually sleep.
Frequently Asked Questions
No. Thread count is one factor among several. A 400 thread count sheet made from short-staple cotton can feel worse than a 200 thread count sheet made from Pima or Egyptian long-staple cotton. Focus on fiber quality first, thread count second.
Percale cotton or bamboo-derived fabric. Both breathe well and wick moisture efficiently. Avoid sateen and flannel if you tend to sleep warm.
Almost always a pocket depth issue. Measure your mattress height and choose sheets with at least 2 inches more pocket depth than your mattress is tall.
Yes. New sheets often contain chemical finishes applied during manufacturing. Washing 2–3 times removes residue and softens the fabric.
It means the sheets were not treated with the standard chemical finishing agents. A good option if you have skin sensitivities or chemical allergies.
Genuine Egyptian long-staple cotton is among the best available — softer, more durable, and better-feeling than standard cotton. The caveat: the label "Egyptian cotton" is often misused. Look for GIZA certification or buy from reputable brands.
Ready to Find Your Perfect Mattress?
Free white glove delivery. 120-night comfort trial. 0% APR financing.


